Morale Dilemma: Should Your Kids Be on Facebook?

by Ivan on February 20, 2011

Should Your Kids use Facebook? It’s a pretty straightforward question and, for most parents, the answer is No. But, life is never that simple. This raises other issues: should kids have a mobile phone, or a Playstation, or big Macs? Here are some dos and don’ts.

facebook-business-page-example

Should Kids Be on Facebook?

The first point is that Facebook is, I believe, for over 18s. But, it’s a real world and under 18s get into pubs, bars, movies and so on.

Of course, this doesn’t make it right or justify shoddy monitoring.

Nor, does it abdicate responsibility from the store owners or Facebook.

Strictly speaking in an ideal world kids wouldn’t be on Facebook, right?

But, if they are not on Facebook, then where do they hang out online?

Why Kids Use Facebook

With the breakdown of the family unit and the tendency of kids to spend more time indoors – getting them out of the house is an issue now – it’s understandable that they want to connect online.

  • Kids use Facebook to connect with each other. It’s a logical extension of texting each other, which paradoxically is another issue.
  • Kids use Facebook to express themselves.
  • Kids use Facebook to connect with distant friends.
  • Kids use Facebook as they are more digital savvy. What’s an issue to you is the norm to them.
  • Kids use Facebook to form groups (as they do offline) and share information with their inner circle.
  • Kids use Facebook to demonstrate loyalty to each other. I’ll friend you but not him.

How Kids Abuse Facebook

But then there is the less pleasant side.

  • Kids use Facebook to intimidate others – as they do offline.
  • Kids use Facebook to exclude others – as they do offline.
  • Kids use Facebook to isolate themselves – as they do offline.

The pattern here is that most of what happens is mirrored offline.

The difference is that the expression – eg likes v party invitation – has changed.

Kids on Facebook – Dos and Don’ts

I lived in the UK, USA, and China most of my adult life. My spectrum of friends is worldwide. Indeed I have more distant friends than local ones. Sound familiar?

And our kids are the same. Thus the attraction of Facebook when they want to connect.

But this still doesn’t explain how to manage Facebook when your kids want to use it. So, here’s what we did.

  • Tell them that you will periodically check their Facebook page to make sure all is well. Don’t spy on them. Be honest and they will respect you more.
  • Before they use Facebook explain how it works. Show them how you use Facebook’s security settings.
  • Change their privacy settings so that only friends – and not friends of friends – can see their pictures, posts etc.
  • Explain what to do if/when they start to get bullied, harassed etc.
  • Remind them that not everyone will accept your friend request.
  • Change the Facebook settings to Https so the connection is more secure and others can’t hack into it. See Privacy settings.
  • Teach them how to create a strong password.

Like I said, the easy option would be to ban Facebook in the house. But this can backfire.

Conclusion

Studies have shown that discussing these issues – and other sensitive issues such as alcohol usage, drugs etc – is more productive than hiding and pretending that it will go away.

The challenge is to help your child navigate its way through life. Facebook is one of the many little journeys they will have to make.

The challenge for us is to show – not tell – the best ways to use these tools to enhance their life.

These are some ideas I quickly put together this Sunday morning before we head off to mass, so forgive the poor grammar in parts.

Please share your thoughts – and this blog post – with your friends.

Need help with your web writing? Click here for a Free Quote


Click here to get a free quote

  • http://www.mikelopez.com/ Mike Lopez

    Very timely especially for me who have two daughters who are below 18 and still have a Facebook account. Yes, they did cheat on their birthday just to get in but as you said, I can tell them not to do it and still they will – one way or another. So instead of banning them from Facebook, I did pretty much what you said. I did get two extra things from this post though.

    1. About privacy settings – set it to Friends Only
    2. The HTTPS thing.

    Thanks!

  • http://www.TheFranchiseKingBlog.com The Franchise King

    Thanks a lot for this post, Ivan.

    Quite frankly, I can’t stand the “attitude that the FB execs have about pretty much anything..especially our privacy.

    JL

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh

    Hi Joel,

    Exactly, you have to see things for what they are.

    I know I’ll never get it 100% right as a parent and regardless of what Facebook execs say and do, you got to take precautions with your kids online and not assume others will do this.

    PS – did you get the message I sent you on Facebook? It’s about an article I’m writing on franchises?

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh

    Hi Joel,

    Exactly, you have to see things for what they are.

    I know I’ll never get it 100% right as a parent and regardless of what Facebook execs say and do, you got to take precautions with your kids online and not assume others will do this.

    PS – did you get the message I sent you on Facebook? It’s about an article I’m writing on franchises?

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh

    Hi Mike,

    When I was a kid in Ireland, MTV was banned. Remember MTV? It seems pretty harmless now but then it was (for us!) very controversial.

    It took a long time to get a handle on it and by then the web had started, so we had to re-think things all over again.

    My take is that it’s best to talk these things through with you kids and give them the best information you can, such as using HTTPs and changing the privacy settings.

    Have to say I’m amazed (maybe not if I’m honest) that some folks don’t make the effort to learn how it works and protect their kids.

    On a side note, I would pay for a premium ‘kids-friendly’ version of Facebook and I think many parents would too.

  • Anonymous

    MTV banned in Ireland? Was it banned nationally, or just in your home? The first time I recall seeing MTV was in the early 90s on Satellite TV. Then again that was in the North, so maybe it was different in the South.

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh

    From what I remember it had the same issues that Monty Python had and only came on our screens after much wringing of hands. We missed the first few years but then it was broadcast.

    Remember Fab Vinny?

  • http://www.TheFranchiseKingBlog.com The Franchise King

    Yes. you know what..I think my email to you bounced. Here- thefranchiseking@sbcglobal.net

  • http://www.facebook.com/kasesq94 Kathleen Scanlon-Desio

    I believe the age requirement is 13 not 18…

    Having said that, I think banning children from Facebook is foolish and almost impossible to enforce.

    Further, it encourages collaboration, interaction and writing – see http://www.livescience.com/8161-teen-blogging-good-study-suggests.html.

    It is also a way to teach them social etiquette. As a parent, it is our responsibility to teach them internet safety, etiquette and so forth. It is also an excellent tool to teach them about cyberbullying – what it is and how to handle it in the best way possible.

    Kathleen
    http://baldwinlocality.com

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh

    Hi Kathleen,

    You’re right, it’s 13.

    What’s interesting about Facebook is that the same dynamics apply online as offline. Like you said, we need to help our kids navigate the choppy waters and provide the best direction we can – it’s an inexact science though and hard to always get the balance right.

    For example, video games are another sensitive area. Where do you draw the line?

    I know some parents who ban them in the home but I wonder what impact this has down-stream when kids are left to their own devices.

    Regards,

    Ivan

Previous post:

Next post: