Case Study: How Copyblogger Shifted From Blog Publishing To Product Development

by Ivan on November 3, 2011

Have you noticed how Copyblogger is moving from a ‘traditional’ blog to a solutions provider offering web marketing tools? Some people feel that Copyblogger should have stuck to its roots and built a better blog, but I’m not so sure.

As they say, “To stay in business, you need to be in business.”

What Copyblogger’s currently doing allows it to scale, integrate, and increases its capital value.

How many blogs can you say that about?

Web Business Models: Which work best?

Let’s back up a second. Most ‘blogs’ struggle to make money.

Why?

Their business model relies on revenue streams that are often beyond its control.

The three most common forms of revenue generation on the web are:

  • Advertising
  • Services
  • Products

Advertising is the one most start with.

It’s very easy to add Google Adsense to your site. However, you need a phenomenal amount of traffic to make a genuine living from it. Trust me, you really do. And anyone telling you otherwise is telling a porky.

  • Services are fine but they’re hard to scale. There are only so many hours in the day. You can’t service clients in your sleep. Try it!
  • Products are the most difficult to develop. But the most lucrative… if you get it right.

 

What’s interesting for me is how Copyblogger developed a path that allowed it to escape from the blogging thread-mill and create something more substantial, with more value, and less dependency on web traffic.

Using your blog as a platform

If you go back to when Copyblogger started, it was like most blogs except that it identified, isolated and owned its niche very quickly. It grew incredibly fast.

This allowed it developed educational tools, such as Teaching Sells, which appealed to its readers.

However, the problem was scale.

Teaching Sells was/is limited to a number of subscribers. My understanding is that it’s run every year, sells out, and then re-runs the next year.

But wouldn’t something the sells 24×7 make more money?

Developing Complementary Solutions

Copyblogger moved into product development a few years ago with the Thesis Theme. This is probably the top-selling premium WordPress theme.

For different reasons, Copyblogger separated from the Thesis Theme developer and created their own offering – The Genesis Framework.

What’s interesting here is that what started as a copywriting site began to offer products that complemented their readers’ needs.

Copyblogger started to develop web products, built upon a strong brand name, that helped bloggers, ie their army of loyal readers, to be more successful.

At the moment, it offers three main products:

  • StudioPress for Blog Design
  • Scribe for Web Traffic
  • Premise for creating Landing Pages

Scaling

The advantage of having this suite of products is obvious:

  • Affiliates help spread the word and create more sales.
  • It’s less dependent on weaker business models, such as advertising which has taken a huge hit in the recession.
  • It can integrate these products with other partners
  •  Upsell opportunities can be realized by selling premium and enterprise versions

Conclusion

Here’s another way of looking at it. Take a look at the AdAdge Power 150 and see which of the sites in the top twenty you’d like to own.

  • Which sites have the best opportunities for revenue generation and licensing?
  • Which sites can be scaled, i.e. build other products upon what’s already there?
  • Which sites can expand into other verticals and industries?

Most sites cannot scale, have few independent revenue streams, and are vulnerable to competition.

What’s interesting about Copyblogger is how it’s building for the future. Instead of building a better blog, it’s building a better business.

What do you think? Is Copyblogger making the right move? Has it abandoned its roots? What do you think it will do next?

Need help with your web writing? Click here for a Free Quote


Click here to get a free quote

  • http://www.copyblogger.com Brian Clark

    FYI, we’re also building a better blog. We’re offering more content, in more formats, than ever before. It’s still the content that attracts people into the Copyblogger universe, and more importantly, keeps them there.

    Thanks for the write up. You’re otherwise right on track in your analysis.

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh, Media Writer

    You’re right, Brian. 

    Didn’t mean to diminish the good work on the blog if that’s what you’re referring to. The podcast is pure gold, btw. 

    Thanks for dropping by. 

  • Anna Thompson

    I stopped reading Copyblogger when Brian stopped writing. Come back, Brian :)

  • http://www.how-to-play-bass.com/ Paul Wolfe

    Ivan

    Interesting post. 

    I think there’s no ‘one model’ that fits all people who use a blog.  At the end of the day Copyblogger is a business first and foremost – the scuds of free and valuable content is there to – as Brian says above – attract people into the Copyblogger universe.

    I think that the model of ‘create content and monetize with advertizing’ is several years old.  Which in ‘blogging years’ is decades.  Brian and Copyblogger Media have developed a suite of tools and products that they wish to sell – I see nothing to get excited about in that.

    In fact I may even model (i.e. creatively ‘steal’) elements of this layout for my bass guitar website when it gets revamped later 2011/early 2012.  The first person who needs to promote your products is YOU – if you have good products that you believe in why relegate them to a minor ‘square’ in your sidebar?

    Paul

  • http://genuineseo.net Eddie Gear

    Ivan this is great. I have written down one half of this article and am
    yet to complete the post. I was also intrigued by the change that
    copyblogger Brian made to his blog. I believe its a good change. As
    Copyblogger is more of a network now and not just a blog. Love the
    review that you have done and I am sure that Brian will have to tweek
    the site more as I am sure that it does not convert as well as they
    might have thought.

  • http://twohourblogger.com Martyn Chamberlin

    Copyblogger has made a smart move. There’s debate over how smart their redesign is for the home page, but the concept is rock solid. 

    Real quick, this clarifies why Thesis and Copyblogger parted ways: http://technosailor.com/2010/07/29/exclusive-interview-brian-clark-leaves-diythemesthesis-theme/

    Also, Studiopress existed long before it merged with Copyblogger LLC (that link clarifies). 

    Interesting article Ivan, and thanks for the share.

  • http://bizdharma.com Himanshu Chanda

    While using blog as a platform to launch products or monetizing is all good, I believe copyblogger has taken the RIGHT step in the WRONG direction….

    Dont get me wrong but as a copyblogger fan I visited CB for all the awesome content that I received. Today when I get on to the website:
    - I first see a call to action
    - Then 3 big bad ass ad placements
    - Below the fold is another call to subscribe to the nesletter
    - Below that is the same menu more enlarged
    - Last there is content… Served more like a feature box

    I guess content which made CB what it is today is given the laaasssttt priority. I find that foolish (Sorry if this hurts other CB fans but this is a genuine feedback).

    Picture this with what Seth Godin (all of us love this guy) does. Write good content. Comments, shares, all tht stuff goes to hell ! Just plain good content. Once u get hooked to that you try to figure out what Seth does. Oh! hez a writer lemme check his books, Oh he has a few webapps let me signup.

    People like to buy they dont want to be sold! I guess CB is trying to sell now. Open to your views

  • http://www.copyblogger.com Brian Clark

    The thing is, people don’t come to the home page for content. Content is delivered by RSS and email, and shared on Twitter and Facebook. In other words, people typically hit a content page first, then click over the homepage.

    Morever, we’ve been “selling” for years. Generally that required us to enter promotions into the content stream for StudioPress, Premise, Scribe, etc. People don’t mind that, because those products are directly related to the content we provide.

    So, all the new home page does is organize us as a business, not just a blog. No one has to see the homepage at all if they subscribe like 155,000 people do – by RSS and email.

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh, Media Writer

    Hi Brian. 

    I know that a lot of existing subscribers visit the site via rss and email, i.e. come in deep. 

    Saying that, I tend to dip into CB every few months, maybe when looking for inspiration, and go to the homepage…

    What surprised me last week when I arrived was that I didn’t see where the blog had gone to. The blog link on the top nav is very subtle and I didn’t see it at first.

    Maybe that’s just me. 

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh, Media Writer

    Thanks Martyn, 

    Websysthesis is another product from the CB Media stable.   http://websynthesis.com/

    Like you said, moving into product development makes sense as it allows the company to expand into new revenue streams and provide tools that serve its current community. 

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh, Media Writer

    Thanks Eddie, 

    I guess for me, as a long time reader, Copyblogger is synonymous with the blog. 

    Copyblogger Media is, as I understand it, the umbrella company under which all the product offering will be developed and served. 

    http://www.copyblogger.com/copyblogger-media/ 

    I guess there is – or was – an argument for creating a dedicated site for CB Media and leaving the blog as it is. 

    There’s pros and cons to both options. It will interesting to see how the current site continues to evolve as more products come onstream :)

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh, Media Writer

    Thanks Eddie, 

    I guess for me, as a long time reader, Copyblogger is synonymous with the blog. 

    Copyblogger Media is, as I understand it, the umbrella company under which all the product offering will be developed and served. 

    http://www.copyblogger.com/copyblogger-media/ 

    I guess there is – or was – an argument for creating a dedicated site for CB Media and leaving the blog as it is. 

    There’s pros and cons to both options. It will interesting to see how the current site continues to evolve as more products come onstream :)

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh, Media Writer

    Thanks Eddie, 

    I guess for me, as a long time reader, Copyblogger is synonymous with the blog. 

    Copyblogger Media is, as I understand it, the umbrella company under which all the product offering will be developed and served. 

    http://www.copyblogger.com/copyblogger-media/ 

    I guess there is – or was – an argument for creating a dedicated site for CB Media and leaving the blog as it is. 

    There’s pros and cons to both options. It will interesting to see how the current site continues to evolve as more products come onstream :)

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh, Media Writer

    Thanks Eddie, 

    I guess for me, as a long time reader, Copyblogger is synonymous with the blog. 

    Copyblogger Media is, as I understand it, the umbrella company under which all the product offering will be developed and served. 

    http://www.copyblogger.com/copyblogger-media/ 

    I guess there is – or was – an argument for creating a dedicated site for CB Media and leaving the blog as it is. 

    There’s pros and cons to both options. It will interesting to see how the current site continues to evolve as more products come onstream :)

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh, Media Writer

    Thanks Eddie, 

    I guess for me, as a long time reader, Copyblogger is synonymous with the blog. 

    Copyblogger Media is, as I understand it, the umbrella company under which all the product offering will be developed and served. 

    http://www.copyblogger.com/copyblogger-media/ 

    I guess there is – or was – an argument for creating a dedicated site for CB Media and leaving the blog as it is. 

    There’s pros and cons to both options. It will interesting to see how the current site continues to evolve as more products come onstream :)

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh, Media Writer

    Thanks Eddie, 

    I guess for me, as a long time reader, Copyblogger is synonymous with the blog. 

    Copyblogger Media is, as I understand it, the umbrella company under which all the product offering will be developed and served. 

    http://www.copyblogger.com/copyblogger-media/ 

    I guess there is – or was – an argument for creating a dedicated site for CB Media and leaving the blog as it is. 

    There’s pros and cons to both options. It will interesting to see how the current site continues to evolve as more products come onstream :)

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh, Media Writer

    Thanks Eddie, 

    I guess for me, as a long time reader, Copyblogger is synonymous with the blog. 

    Copyblogger Media is, as I understand it, the umbrella company under which all the product offering will be developed and served. 

    http://www.copyblogger.com/copyblogger-media/ 

    I guess there is – or was – an argument for creating a dedicated site for CB Media and leaving the blog as it is. 

    There’s pros and cons to both options. It will interesting to see how the current site continues to evolve as more products come onstream :)

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh, Media Writer

    Thanks Eddie, 

    I guess for me, as a long time reader, Copyblogger is synonymous with the blog. 

    Copyblogger Media is, as I understand it, the umbrella company under which all the product offering will be developed and served. 

    http://www.copyblogger.com/copyblogger-media/ 

    I guess there is – or was – an argument for creating a dedicated site for CB Media and leaving the blog as it is. 

    There’s pros and cons to both options. It will interesting to see how the current site continues to evolve as more products come onstream :)

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh, Media Writer

    Thanks Eddie, 

    I guess for me, as a long time reader, Copyblogger is synonymous with the blog. 

    Copyblogger Media is, as I understand it, the umbrella company under which all the product offering will be developed and served. 

    http://www.copyblogger.com/copyblogger-media/ 

    I guess there is – or was – an argument for creating a dedicated site for CB Media and leaving the blog as it is. 

    There’s pros and cons to both options. It will interesting to see how the current site continues to evolve as more products come onstream :)

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh, Media Writer

    Thanks Eddie, 

    I guess for me, as a long time reader, Copyblogger is synonymous with the blog. 

    Copyblogger Media is, as I understand it, the umbrella company under which all the product offering will be developed and served. 

    http://www.copyblogger.com/copyblogger-media/ 

    I guess there is – or was – an argument for creating a dedicated site for CB Media and leaving the blog as it is. 

    There’s pros and cons to both options. It will interesting to see how the current site continues to evolve as more products come onstream :)

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh, Media Writer

    Thanks Eddie, 

    I guess for me, as a long time reader, Copyblogger is synonymous with the blog. 

    Copyblogger Media is, as I understand it, the umbrella company under which all the product offering will be developed and served. 

    http://www.copyblogger.com/copyblogger-media/ 

    I guess there is – or was – an argument for creating a dedicated site for CB Media and leaving the blog as it is. 

    There’s pros and cons to both options. It will interesting to see how the current site continues to evolve as more products come onstream :)

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh, Media Writer

    Thanks Eddie, 

    I guess for me, as a long time reader, Copyblogger is synonymous with the blog. 

    Copyblogger Media is, as I understand it, the umbrella company under which all the product offering will be developed and served. 

    http://www.copyblogger.com/copyblogger-media/ 

    I guess there is – or was – an argument for creating a dedicated site for CB Media and leaving the blog as it is. 

    There’s pros and cons to both options. It will interesting to see how the current site continues to evolve as more products come onstream :)

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh, Media Writer

    Thanks Eddie, 

    I guess for me, as a long time reader, Copyblogger is synonymous with the blog. 

    Copyblogger Media is, as I understand it, the umbrella company under which all the product offering will be developed and served. 

    http://www.copyblogger.com/copyblogger-media/ 

    I guess there is – or was – an argument for creating a dedicated site for CB Media and leaving the blog as it is. 

    There’s pros and cons to both options. It will interesting to see how the current site continues to evolve as more products come onstream :)

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh, Media Writer

    Thanks Eddie, 

    I guess for me, as a long time reader, Copyblogger is synonymous with the blog. 

    Copyblogger Media is, as I understand it, the umbrella company under which all the product offering will be developed and served. 

    http://www.copyblogger.com/copyblogger-media/ 

    I guess there is – or was – an argument for creating a dedicated site for CB Media and leaving the blog as it is. 

    There’s pros and cons to both options. It will interesting to see how the current site continues to evolve as more products come onstream :)

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh, Media Writer

    Thanks Eddie, 

    I guess for me, as a long time reader, Copyblogger is synonymous with the blog. 

    Copyblogger Media is, as I understand it, the umbrella company under which all the product offering will be developed and served. 

    http://www.copyblogger.com/copyblogger-media/ 

    I guess there is – or was – an argument for creating a dedicated site for CB Media and leaving the blog as it is. 

    There’s pros and cons to both options. It will interesting to see how the current site continues to evolve as more products come onstream :)

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh, Media Writer

    Thanks Paul,

    I use blogging primarily for lead generation and, like you said, sell products and services that cascade out of that. 

    I’m a big fan of CopyBlogger and was curious to see how it’s business model has evolved. Some parts I do undersand, whereas others I’m less enthusiastic about.

    Will keep an eye on your site. Big bass guitar fan here! Love some of the line work from Adam in U2. 

  • Antoine Bonicalzi

    I found Copy Blogger only two months ago. Actually I bought the premise plugin (via appsumo) and then fell in love with the wonderful content! I have been a huge fan since then. I formed a habit of going to the homepage once in a while…for inspiration or because I felt like reading a good article. So yes, I was surprised to see the new homepage. I have to say, the link to the blog could be more visible, or it could even be a link for free marketing advice or something like that. 

    As a business example, I like what they did though. The new home page gives a better idea of all the things the business can do for their customers. You know what this is all about within 30 seconds. It does a great job of positioning the whole copy blogger business.

    I know I said it earlier, but I would only suggest an obvious link to the marketing advice above the fold!

    P.S. Ivan, great job of creating a discussion! 

  • http://www.guruduweb.com/ Antoine Bonicalzi

    I would be curious to know if the opt in form on the home page gets a good conversion rate compared to the call to action they have below their blog post…just curious!

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh, Media Writer

    I’ve heard that if someone makes the effort to read to the end of an article, then you have a  higher chance of converting AND retaining them. 

    I assume this is because they are that little bit more interested. 

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh, Media Writer

    I was surprised too that the blog link wasn’t a different color or used some device to make it stand out. I really didn’t see it until I looked very carefully and most people won’t do that. 

  • http://www.copyblogger.com Brian Clark

    The home page opt-in box for IMfSP is outperforming the end of post version by a steady 85%. For the first week opt-ins increased by over 100%.

  • http://www.copyblogger.com Brian Clark

    >>>I guess there is – or was – an argument for creating a dedicated site for CB Media and leaving the blog as it is.

    Yes, a bad one. ;-)

    Take a look at 37signals. Look how they evolved, from a design firm with a blog, to a popular blog, to a software company. There is precedent for what we’ve done, and it’s working well.

    In one of our future podcasts, I’ll lay out the reasoning behind what we did, and what the results have been so far.

  • http://couchable.co Tyler Herman

    Great Read. I totally agree with you about using your blog as a platform. Have to funnel that traffic into something more lucrative than ad clicks.. 

    Just like the people who made the most money in the gold rush were the inns, general stores selling supplies to the miners. Copyblogger is selling tools (WP Themes) to all the starry eyed bloggers out there (ourselves included) trying to make it rich. 

  • http://www.ivanwalsh.com Ivan Walsh, Media Writer

    Thanks Tyler, 

    Great analogy about the gold rush. I see more bloggers moving from blogging per se to developing tools, such as skins, plugins and apps to generate revenue. 

    The blog is becoming more a lead generation tool, which makes sense of course. 

    Thanks for stopping by :)

    Ivan

Previous post:

Next post: